Writing on the Ether: Following Up on Library Ebooks

Tivoli Gardens, Copenhagen, in holiday mode / Porter Anderson

Deck the halls, not your colleagues
Self-publishing: And a kind word for the publishers?
Following up on library ebooks: A Penguin in Amazonia
Amazonia, Part 1: O’Leary, not cowed by Prime Lending rates
Amazonia, Part 2: Lend me an author
Amazonia, Part 3: Fear and loathing and DRM
Amazonia, Part 4: Revving those reviews
Amazonia, Part 5: The last domino falls
Amazonia, Part 6: Roasting on that open Fire
More self-publishing: The Battle for Book Country
eBooks among us: Getting over it
eBooks and royalties: Autopilot’s end
eBooks and school: While you were eating…
Blog Sommelier: Pair this Jane with that Hamilton
Publishing and news media: Who’s not talking?
Joys of modern media: Britannia feels the waves (of info)
The writing life: Everybody started somewhere
Tidings of some comfort: Our benediction for this week

Deck the halls, not your colleagues

So now it’s December. Backing up the bus and truck for its annual sit-down engagement. Here on the literary road show. Beep-beep-beeping into place.

Heavy production numbers. December comes with all that holiday gear. Snow machines for Mayor Bloomberg. Marley’s chains. The @Rockettes (oh yes, they have their own Twitter handle). One of them is always kicking with the left, not the right. No, she’s kicking with both legs. Oh, sorry, that nutcracker was somebody from Penguin, my mistake. I was blinded by a thousand points of light. Connected to each other by Grinched-up green wires, what ebook-pricing sadist packages those things? It’s showtime, Mr. Tchaikovsky.

Problem is, our loading dock is so freaking full already. Every other tweet screams BUY MY BOOK. How are we going to squeeze in Tiny Tim between Konrath and Manus? Lose the crutch, there’s no room in the inn. He’ll just have to do extra limping. Like this industry.

See, I’m nobody’s Wise Man, but it doesn’t take Three Kings who “from Orient are” to tell you that there’s too much punch in your bowl, Mrs. Fezziwig. Weepy bids for “inspiration” among the blog carolers. Too many nogs, not enough eggs. Lo, such a big pile of Kindling on the hearth, that our Nate Hoffelder at The Digital Reader has taken to waxing elegiac on the e-book edition of Fahrenheit 451:

First they came for Rowling, and I smiled;
Then they came for Bradbury, and I cheered …

When what to my wondering eyes does appear but A Big, Sane Article on Self-Publishing. Free of malice, rancor, and candy-assed sugarplum fairies.

Hark, the herald angel is named Edan Lepucki. Jack Frost wouldn’t dream of nipping at her nose. What kind of a perv do you think he is, anyway? And if the Multitude of the Heavenly Host doesn’t sing backup as Lepucki opens this week’s Ether, it’s because they got into the bourbon backstage before those copywriters could get the new edits done.

Is that an audiobook in your Christmas stocking, or are you just glad to hear me?


[blackbirdpie id=”141276020148932608″]


Self-publishing: And a kind word for the publishers?

The industry has troubles. The slim profit margins of books; the problems of bookstore returns; the quandary of Borders closing and Amazon forever selling books as a loss-leader; how to make people actually pay for content, and so on… And yet. And yet. I read good books by large publishing houses all the time, books that take my breath away, make me laugh and cry and wonder at the brilliance of humanity…I want a reputable publishing house standing behind my book; I want them to tell you it’s good so that I don’t have to.

Lepucki isn’t one to harch off on a tangent. Don’t be fooled by her headline at The Millions, Reasons Not to Self-Publish in 2011-2012, written “in a list format, the pet genre of the blogosphere.” She weighs some real concerns here. Her brother-in-law appears at one point like the Ghost of You Know What, turning up in a bit of a lather, Ebenezer: “Please don’t self-publish!” But Lepucki keeps her head about her and navigates the fruitcake terrain of the business with rooftop-reindeer poise.

The conversation about self-publishing too often ignores the role of independent publishing houses in this shifting reading landscape. Whether larger independents like Algonquin and Graywolf, or small gems like Featherproof and Two Dollar Radio, or university presses like Lookout Books, the imprint at the University of North Carolina, Wilmington…independent presses offer diversity to readers, and provide yet another professional option for authors.

Hey, I heard that “humbug.” So read author Peter Straub‘s comments in Lepucki’s piece:

Most of the editors I have worked with over the past thirty-five years have made crucial contributions to the books entrusted to them, and the copy-editors have always, in every case, done exactly the same. They have enriched the books that came into their hands. Can you have good, thoughtful, creative editing and precise, accurate, immaculate copy-editing if you self-publish? And if you can’t, what is being said about the status or role of selflessness before the final form of the fiction as accepted by the audience, I mean the willingness of the author to submerge his ego to produce the novel that is truest to itself?

“Perhaps the small press world is becoming the real proving ground for literary writers,” Lepucki writes.

Let me direct you to some good notes at Google+ from Guy LeCharles Gonzalez, I’d Prefer a Small Press to a Vanity Press, and his commenters, following up on Lepucki’s article.

A favorite response of mine is Baldur Bjarnason‘s commentary What a publisher does, which notes that Lepucki’s piece is “not as one-sided as you’d think.”


[blackbirdpie id=”141928296572137472″]


Following up on library ebooks: A Penguin in Amazonia

When Penguin announced last week that it was disabling library ebook lending on the Kindle and pulling its latest ebook titles from all library lending platforms, libraries and readers took the hit, but to some observers they were collateral damage in a fight between publishers and Amazon about the control of publishers’ titles… Indeed, Penguin’s move suggests that the publishing industry’s long-simmering concern over Amazon’s dominant position and its aggressive new ventures in the ebook market are coming to a boil.

Andrew Albanese, writing with Jim Milliot at Publisher’s Weekly, builds a clarifying summation of last week’s fracas, aptly titled In Fight with Amazon, Libraries Caught in the Crossfire. “The Penguin controversy could very well reinforce the feeling among the major houses that it is better to wait on the sidelines to see how some of the issues shake out before getting deeply involved with ebook lending, and it is difficult to see holdouts Simon & Schuster or Macmillan changing their minds soon about entering the OverDrive lending program.”

Curbside Haiku / NYC DOT

Curbside Haiku / John Morse was commissioned by New York City’s Department of Transportation to produce a series of these poetic safety warnings, going up on 144 signs.

In the American Library Association’s District Dispatch, Marijke Visser looks to Brian O’Leary’s Opportunity in Abundance presentation from Peter Brantley and O’Reilly’s Books in Browsers conference. Visser, in Sticking a toe in the e-book tsunami , goes for the emotional heat that simmers under this and so many publishing upheavals:

Recent events with ebooks bring much needed attention to the need to be proactive and include all players in a discussion as to how to ameliorate the contentious marketplace in which we find ourselves.

And in the boldest write I’ve seen yet, It’s Not About Libraries, It’s About Amazon, Eric Hellman deftly uses Colorado’s Douglas County libraries’ “Buy This Book” button on its online catalog pages to peer past the Penguinery and take a good look at the polar bear loping toward us:

The Penguin move should be seen not as corporate verdict on libraries, but as a reaction to Amazon’s entry into the library market. When OverDrive was distributing content to libraries on their own platform, the publishers were able to view OverDrive, and libraries in general, as a counterweight to Amazon. But the extension of OverDrive lending to the Kindle flipped libraries into the Amazon column. That’s the best way to understand the Penguin decision, though you won’t see them saying that.

Hands across the water, it’s a note from my recent host country (there is nothing like a Dane). There,  Jennifer Buley at the Copenhagen Post writes of how it goes when Denmark’s Libraries get into the digital book business.

Each time a book is loaned out, the library pays the publisher a use fee – 18.5 kroner [about US$3.30] for new releases and 15 kroner [about US$2.70] for ones more than one year old. The more a title is borrowed, the lower the fee to the library. But to the patron, it’s always free. The individual libraries decide how many digital books patrons may borrow and for how long. In Copenhagen, users can borrow up to five ebooks per month for up to one month each…“It’s a huge worry for a lot of us,” Elisabeth Fogtdal, legal manager of Gyldendal, Denmark’s largest publisher, told Politiken newspaper. “On the other hand, eReolen could also give the commercial ebook market – which has been really sluggish in this country – a positive lift.”

And another country heard from. Here’s the Calgary Public Library Foundation site, developed by transmedia specialist Kevin Franco and his team.

With an initial investment by the city, the Calgary Public Library is poised to create an all new central library for all Calgarians. It will be unlike any other library in the world; a beacon of modern learning and community. We want to discover what a library of the 21st century can be, so we’re asking you.

I still love the grand gesture. And getting onto a site in Calgary and writing “Cities across the globe are waiting to see what the Calgary Public Library does next” is audaciously grand, is it not? They may dig out of all this before anybody else.


[blackbirdpie id=”141669995909357568″]


Amazonia, Part 1: O’Leary, not cowed by Prime Lending rates

Amazon’s offering free content to Prime members could be interpreted many ways: as a demonstrable belief in digital reading; a continued push for the Kindle platform; a test to evaluate the impact of free content on purchase behavior; or even a revival of the “book of the month” concept. So far, authors, agents, and some publishers seem to think of it another way: theft.

With typically even-handed understanding of the noisy qualms on all sides, Brian O’Leary points how  healthy it might be to look at Amazon’s trial lending program for Prime members as what it is: An Experiment.

Certainly, that’s Amazon’s argument, although, as O’Reilly Media’s Joe Wikert has blogged, Amazon’s terms may not be what publishers want or deserve. Here’s the thing about terms, though: most of them presume a static world. The world of content distribution is changing, however, and the models for delivering content are evolving at a rapid pace. For the moment, we need not qualify the Amazon Prime ebook lending program as the future of publishing or its inevitable demise. We need to call it what it is: an experiment. I can understand how free digital content undermines contracts written for the physical world. We might yearn for higher prices and windowed releases. But at some point, the cost of holding fast to what we’ve known exceeds the benefit. Maybe it already does.


[blackbirdpie id=”139080780881207296″]


Amazonia, Part 2: Lend me an author

As of December 1, Amazon intends to add Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) titles to the lending library. Authors approached by Amazon to participate say the company is offering a chance to share in a large pool of licensing cash–but requiring complete exclusivity in exchange. The money pool, according to those familiar with the offer, is $500,000 a month over the next 12 months, or $6 million in total. But Amazon requires that participants remove their titles from sale at all other ebook retailers.

In Kindle Lending Library Reaches Out to KDP Authors–With Cash, Michael Cader at Publishers Lunch writes up the inclusion of books self-published in the KDP program.

Curbside Haiku / John Morse for the New York City DOT

Curbside Haiku / John Morse for the New York City DOT

I have permission to quote, on condition of anonymity here, a particularly eloquent industry specialist whose work with many successful authors, both traditionally and self-published, offers an insight into how the Amazonian move is being received.

Those authors who have been successful in pricing experimentally–even for free–have sold enough books to understand the halo effect, and to know that going free for a short period can work. So some are putting their books in the Lending Library simply in order to have the option to use the free price. When you’re hungry for marketing opportunities, and the retailers hold all the power and you have no relationship with the major channels, an opportunity like this can be seen as really valuable. Quite the carrot.

How much of a carrot? Author Jennie Coughlin in her post Is Amazon Using Its Market Presence to Break The Big Six? is following author Robert Bidinotto‘s progress in the program.

If you were at Kindle Boards over the weekend, you might have seen the thread where four KB indie authors were invited by Amazon to participate in a Black Friday promotion that started Sunday. Robert was one of them, and he was featured as an editor’s pick. By the end of the weekend, his debut novel Hunter: A Thriller had passed thriller writers Stephen King and James Patterson – including Patterson’s new Alex Cross novel — in the bestseller lists. As of Tuesday night, he had sold more than 8,000 books through this promotion. It’s currently ranked 8th in sales among all paid Kindle books…. He described his reaction last night: “What’s happening is unreal right now. I can’t believe it…but I just blew by STEPHEN KING.”


[blackbirdpie id=”140422369939439616″]


Amazonia, Part 3: Fear and loathing and DRM

As ebook sales mushroom, the Big Six’s insistence on DRM has proven to be a hideous mistake. Rather than reducing piracy, it has locked customers in Amazon’s walled garden, which in turn increases Amazon’s leverage over publishers. And unlike pirated copies (which don’t automatically represent lost sales) Amazon is a direct revenue threat because Amazon have no qualms about squeezing their suppliers — or trying to poach authors for their “direct” publishing channel by offering initially favourable terms. (Which will doubtless get a lot less favourable once the monopoly is secured …)

Charlie Stross joins those wondering if publishers’ Amazon fears haven’t got them Cutting their own throats.


[blackbirdpie id=”141227843341385729″]


Amazonia, Part 4: Revving those reviews

While consumer purchasing will always be influenced by the prevailing tactics and technology of the current environment, consumer psychology hasn’t really changed much in the last millennium. While how readers buy and read books is changing, why they read has not.  The Rosetta Stone of author marketing is simply this — know your reader and what they want.

Robert Trahan responds here to Amazon Reader Reviews: 12 Things Everybody and His Grandmother Needs to Know by Anne R. Allen, who seems to have heard from everybody and their grandfathers about it.


[blackbirdpie id=”141971147171430401″]


Amazonia, Part 5: The last domino falls

The Domino Project’s last print book, its twelfth, is an illustrated hardcover version of B, a poem by Sarah Kay. The imprint will also publish a “digital bonus,” and then will not publish any more new titles. “As far as I know, all the books will continue to be promoted and sold,” Godin told me. “No reason for that to change.”

Laura Hazard Owen, in reporting No More New Titles For Seth Godin’s Amazon Imprint, The Domino Project at paidContent, makes the point, “It seems unlikely that Amazon is pulling its support, since the books have sold so well—much better than most of Amazon Publishing’s other titles, in fact, at least in print.”

But from the gnomic Godin’s own heavily scrutinized blog post, The last hardcover, we get his focus on what he terms the “permission” of a developed subscription base. And while he calls the project a success – “Projects are fun to start, but part of the deal is that they don’t last forever” – he’s putting it down, as eyebrows go up.

Permission is still the most important and valuable asset of the web (and of publishing). The core group of 50,000 subscribers to the Domino blog made all the difference in getting the word out and turning each of our books into a bestseller. It still amazes me how few online merchants and traditional publishers (and even authors) have done the hard work necessary to create this asset. If you’re an author in search of success and you don’t pursue this with singleminded passion, you’re making a serious error.

Not so fast, say some industry watchers.

Curbside Haiku / John Morse for the New York City DOT

“It’s not the way to market in the future; it’s a way to market in the future,” says Mike Shatzkin to Jeremy Greenfield at Digital Book World in Is Seth Godin Right About Book Publishing?

Of course, “for novels and for narrative non-fiction, there is clearly a role for a third party to aggregate readers who are interested in the kinds of books that those authors write,” says Simon Lipskar to Greenfield, in reference to the “permission” tribe buying Godin’s output.  “There is a substantive and real role for publishers to find readers.”

Greenfield concludes, “In addition to building their own ‘tribes’ and gathering ‘permission,’ the book business still has other ways of selling books.”

A host of comments on the topic reflects skepticism. With Camp Godin chanting that all the Dominos were falling so beautifully, it’s not easy to reconcile the fact that Godin has picked up his  aphorisms and walked.

Michael Cader at Publishers Lunch observes in  Godin’s Domino Project Wraps Up:

Without complete statistics, which are not disclosed, we don’t know if The Domino Project actually maximized either unit sales or dollar sales for Godin. Being exclusive to Amazon in ebook was probably a factor.

And here’s the Loudpoet again, Guy LeCharles Gonzalez, in Spinning Dominoes: Don’t Believe the Hype… But DO Learn From It to help us get those dominos back into the box. (You can quit poking it now.)

Has it really been only nine months since The Domino Project’s first release, Poke the Box, a disappointing retread of his traditionally published and far superior Tribes?…Godin is shutting The Domino Project down, offering the awkward explanation that “it was a project, not a lifelong commitment to being a publisher of books,” instead of, perhaps, admitting that publishing is harder than it looks if you want to swim at the deep end of the trade pool in the middle of a dramatic transition, as he obliquely acknowledges in many of his noteworthy takeaways.

Ebooks aren’t magic; having a platform doesn’t mean you don’t have to do the work; and, most importantly, in the digital era, distribution is the easy part. It’s also a part that Godin took a calculated gamble on by limiting himself to Amazon and the Kindle platform, and it will be very interesting to see where he goes for his next book after so boldly proclaiming he was done with traditional publishing last summer…I think we can safely add The Domino Project to the ever-growing list of wannabe disruptors who get tons of hype only to fade away into bit players or complete irrelevance.


[blackbirdpie id=”141542737542516737″]


Amazonia, Part 6: Roasting on that open Fire

Even before the busy holiday shopping weekend, we’d already sold millions of the new Kindle family and Kindle Fire was the bestselling product across all of Amazon.com. Black Friday was the best ever for the Kindle family – customers purchased 4X as many Kindle devices as they did last Black Friday – and last year was a great year… we’re seeing a lot of customers buying multiple Kindles – one for themselves and others as gifts – we expect this trend to continue on … through the holiday shopping season.

Everything’s coming up poinsettias, reports Dave Limp, VP in Amazon’s Kindle division, in the company’s press release, Best Black Friday Ever for Kindle Family: Kindle Sales Increase 4X Over Last Year.


[blackbirdpie id=”141512510200217600″]


More self-publishing: The Battle for Book Country

In case I was wrong and Book Country was selling self-pubbed books on the Penguin site, I checked the Penguin website. I searched the site for any mention of Book Country or Book Country distributed books. I searched the ebook offerings. I found nothing that mentions Book Country. There might be something there, but it is buried so deeply that only a master researcher could find it.

That’s J W Manus  in her post and comments and comments-on-comments,  Review: Penguin’s Book Country As A Retail Site.

Colleen Lindsay, community manager for Book Country (@Book_Country, remember, tweet fans), reponds on many points, including the one in our quote above:

You can’t find any books for sale yet on Book Country because the Publish portion of the site has existed for less than two weeks. Publishing a book using Book Country’s self-publishing services means that the author must wait 2-3 days for a PDF proof to approve; once the proof is approved, it can take up to three weeks for the book to appear on sale on the Book Country. Since the site has existed for less than two weeks, it makes sense that you would not be able to see books for purchase appearing on the Genre Map or anywhere else on the site.


[blackbirdpie id=”141541308635414528″]


[blackbirdpie id=”141541509181878272″]


[blackbirdpie id=”141722148707373056″]


eBooks among us: Getting over it

This is a “both/and” world, not an “either/or” world. For a long time to come, we’re going to have printed books right alongside digital books. Many of us will continue to buy both. They’re all “real” books. There’s no reason you can’t embrace both, no reason to demonize digital technology. And if you’re a writer, there’s reason to think e-books are the best thing that could have happened to you, because people who have e-readers seem to be buying more books overall, both digital and print.

In a post headlined eBooks vs. “Real” Books, agent Rachelle Gardner does Assisi duty—doves settling all over her, what a mess—to say, “No more ‘dark side’ (of ebooks). No more ‘real’ books versus whatever. Let’s all just enjoy books in the medium of our choice.”

Bit of an echo, CNET-head Nathan Bransford conducts another of his totally informal, completely unscientific, “entertainment only!” polls on readers’ feelings about ebooks and detects “what’s called a trend” when he sees ebook acceptance move from 7 percent in 2007 to 47 percent now among his avid blog readers.

Not being as gracious as Gardner, nor as devoted to the color orange as Bransford, I’ll just add this: If you haven’t yet tried reading a book on an e-reader, you owe it to yourself to borrow somebody’s and give it a spin before you trash the e-medium. “Embarrassment” starts with an “e,” too.


[blackbirdpie id=”141900004347486209″]


eBooks and royalties: Autopilot’s end

My hunch (all hunch, no data) is that in the long run (5 or 10 years?) retailers will find it hard to keep 30% of the consumer’s dollar, publishers will find it nearly impossible to keep 75% of what the retailers pay, and that any author who wants to compete seriously will have a cost structure that will often make a royalty rate taking even as much as half of it away worth considering.

Mike Shatzkin in The ebook value chain is still sorting itself out, and so are the splits looks at the disparities of the moment and weighs a few possibilities. “Right now putting an ebook into Amazon and having them sell it on autopilot can get a lot more of the total market than will be the case over time as a more fully articulated and global ebook infrastructure builds out.”


[blackbirdpie id=”141541876972003328″]


eBooks and school: While you were eating…

Simba Information, a research company specializing in publishing, estimates that electronic textbooks will generate $267.3 million this year in sales in the United States. That is a rise of 44.3 percent over last year. The American Association of Publishers estimates that the college textbooks industry generated a total of $4.58 billion in sales last year. Kathy Micky, a senior analyst at Simba,…estimates that by 2013, digital textbooks will make up 11 percent of the textbook market revenue.

Thanks to a timely tip from Peter Brantley over the poultry-powered holiday, here’s Christopher Schuetze of the International Herald-Tribune in Paris writing Textbooks Finally Take a Big Leap to Digital.


[blackbirdpie id=”140884522072936449″]


Blog Sommelier: Pair this Jane with that Hamilton

I know nothing about you. I don’t know you. And you don’t know me. Let me get a little Gawker sarcasm going – you mean I can spend some time laying out the game plan for a book in an E-mail that’s convenient to your E-mail missives although you may not have the chops or the focus or the genuine interest to put together a book – without actually being your agent? Gee, thanks! That’s an agent that you don’t want. Maybe posting snark in repackaged configurations is the sum total of your talents, know what I mean? Not to mention that I don’t know if Gawker has any official policy regarding such efforts. Books are a whole different species my friend. It doesn’t look like you’re familiar with what it takes. Am I wrong?///Sincerely, Mark Kelley


Curbside Haiku / John Morse for the New York City DOT

Hamilton Nolan gives us that bad boy in How to Be a High-Powered Literary Agent, by a Crazy Person at Gawker. Nolan concludes, “Look for my book, ‘An Expansion of One of My Posts,’ in the spring of 2012. Once I had the inspiration, I didn’t need to pay an agent a cent!”

Pair that with the next day’s post from #JaneFriedman – courageous host of the Ether and hashtag unto herself – giving us this truly useful tip, Turn Your WordPress Blog Into a Book on the fine plug-in for self-hosted WordPressies, Anthologize. It’s just what you need, Hamilton, to produce “An Expansion of One of My Posts” for that spring release.


[blackbirdpie id=”141213765835292672″]


Publishing and news media: Who’s not talking?

Every now and again there are stories in the media (mainly traditional media: newspapers, TV, radio) that doubt the capabilities of the publishing world coping with the shift to digital. That there is truth to be found in this subject is clear, but what stings me (and many others in the publishing world), is that almost all of these stories are poorly justified, blunt and only seem to be made to cause a stir. And none of these traditional media seems to be interested in the side of the publishers. What about hearing both sides? Isn’t that what journalism is all about? Time for the other story to be told!

Timo Boezeman in What nobody sees and what ensures that publishers remain: added value is close to a point after my own heart. Mike Shatzkin commented on this recently, too. We know too little of the pressures on publishers in many instances to make judgments, not that that stops us. Boezeman is writing from Utrecht, where things may be different, so I’ll give him his argument on his home turf. But here in the States, our traditional publishers aren’t always helping. As a group, they’re not good at talking with the press, as I’ve mentioned before on the Ether. The Amazon story can be played as a one-sided rout pretty easily if the other team clenches when they should be talking. Recent example: Penguin could have done a lot more explanatory work about its off-again, on-again library-ebooks shuffle of last week. Legal-whipped as I’m sure everyone is, tension shows, fear has a scent.


[blackbirdpie id=”141632867720626176″]


Joys of modern media: Britannia feels the waves (of info)

This research has shown it doesn’t take much to feel like we’re drowning in data at work. The way we have to work today involves assimilating information from many sources and the fact we’re struggling to do this is a very real business issue – one that will only increase as we enter the big data era. Something as simple as searching for information can have a big effect at a time when businesses are looking to free up employees time to be more innovative and productive in order to stimulate the growth most are looking for in 2012.

That’s Chris Harmon of Mindjet in Emma Barnett‘s Telegraph report on a survey Harmon commissioned, Information overload wastes two weeks a year. Barnett writes:

On average, British workers receive 36 emails in their inbox every day…this seemingly small number of emails (is) leaving employees overwhelmed. The average worker spends over 21 minutes a day searching for information they have seen but cannot find.


[blackbirdpie id=”141618019842527232″]


The writing life: Everybody started somewhere

Anton Chekov was a physician. Laura Ingalls Wilder taught a class of five students in a one-room schoolhouse, and later became secretary-treasurer of the Mansfield Farm Loan Association in Missouri. John Steinbeck spent the summer of 1928 giving tours of a fish hatchery in Lake Tahoe, where he met his future wife. After losing that job in the fall, Steinbeck followed her to San Francisco, where he became a warehouseman at the Bemis Bag Company factory. Margarite Duras wrote technical reports as an assistant in the French Colonial Office, and then worked on publicity for French bananas and tea.

Keyed on high-school teacher Alexis Jenni’s win of Frances’ Prix Goncourt, When Does a Writer Become a Writer?  is an entertaining survey from researcher, Betsy Morais in The Atlantic.


[blackbirdpie id=”141341821711290368″]


Tidings of some comfort: Our benediction for this week

The obvious reason for this literary vacuum is that the Christian faith, and the Catholic Church in particular, have been in full-cultural retreat since the 1960s. In the wake of the sexual revolution and the women’s movement, many Catholics left the Church over its opposition to abortion, artificial contraception, and the ordination of women, to name just a few hot-button topics. And then, beginning in the late 1990s, a wave of priest sex-abuse crimes came to light that have scandalized untold numbers of Catholics.

In Where Have All the Catholic Writers Gone?,  Robert Fay at The Millions points out that ” novels — both by Catholics and non-Catholics — grappling with what used to be called “the drama of salvation” are no longer just rare, but almost unthinkable nowadays.”


[blackbirdpie id=”142037439681265665″]


Porter AndersonPorter Anderson is a Fellow with the National Critics Institute, and a producer and consultant formerly with the United Nations World Food Programme in Rome and INDEX: Design to Improve Life in Copenhagen. As a journalist, he has worked with media including CNN, the Village Voice, and the Dallas Times Herald. He reviews literary fiction at Reader Unboxed, and is based in Tampa.

Posted in Writing on the Ether.

Porter Anderson / @Porter_Anderson

View posts by Porter Anderson / @Porter_Anderson

Porter Anderson (@Porter_Anderson) is a journalist and consultant in publishing. He's The Bookseller's (London) Associate Editor in charge of The FutureBook. He's a featured writer with Thought Catalog (New York), which carries his reports, commentary, and frequent Music for Writers interviews with composers and musicians. And he's a regular contributor of "Provocations in Publishing" with Writer Unboxed. Through his consultancy, Porter Anderson Media, Porter covers, programs, and speaks at publishing conferences and other events in Europe and the US, and works with various players in publishing, such as Library Journal's SELF-e, Frankfurt Book Fair's Business Club, and authors. You can follow his editorial output at Porter Anderson Media, and via this RSS link.

Join the conversation

8 Comment threads
13 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
Be a Tweep, Not a Tool Part 2–Beware the #FF Fire Hose « Kristen Lamb's BlogBlog Treasures 12-2 « Gene Lempp's BlogVictorianoeVictoria MixonAnne R. Allen Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Thanks for the link, Porter! Robert’s agreed to an interview on my blog, so hopefully that will be up by the end of the weekend, depending on both of our schedules. 

Porter Anderson

Hey, @twitter-11541172:disqus , thanks, and glad to know you’ll be interviewing Robert on his Excellent Amazon Adventure 🙂 … we’ll be all ears!

Vaughn Roycroft
Vaughn Roycroft

Wow, what a week. Your opening had me howling. I am most thankful, after losing the crutch and limping on, for your link to Lepucki’s post at The Millions. I knew I was holding off on self-pub for some reason(s). Nice to have them enumerated. Alas, my primary reason for considering it at all – a word count that sends most agents and editors scrambling for the automated rejection send button – still exists. Maybe I should just start a snarky blog, gain some permission by hawking up subscribers, package my long-ass ms as an expansion thereof, and cram it down their throats… Read more »

Porter Anderson

Needless to say, @VaughnRoycroft:twitter , my secretary will disavow all knowledge of your actions. Go forth in good faith, I believe you’ve hit on a plan, snark it up. 🙂 Seriously, you know, if length is an issue (and these days anything longer than Curbside Haiku is too long), you might think about serial publishing. I remain agnostic on the approach, believing frankly that a few things have changed since men were men and Charles Dickens was one of them, but Friend o’ the Ether @RozMorris:twitter did it and survived to talk about it. And another ami-gazeuse, @SeanPlatt:twitter, is also doing… Read more »

Orna Ross

What a summary, wow! Aren’t we the lucky lot to work in this exciting moment for the writing world.  Thanks for the vigilant eye and the elegant summation. 

Porter Anderson

Thank YOU for having a look, @ornaross:twitter, you’re a strong woman. As is my host with the most, @JaneFriedman:twitter; I’ve driven her to drink, you know. Appreciate the tweet and comment –

Orna Ross

Guess that’s why you’re called Porter 🙂  (which, in case you don’t know, is the Irish name for stout beer). 

Dee DeTarsio

Porter, I only understand about 1/3rd of your references, but since I also suck at math that’s probably a wild overestimation. I really enjoy the parts I get–especially the pretty picture of Tivoli Gardens from Copenhagen. (Did you know I am close, personal friends with Hans Christian Andersen?)

Porter Anderson

Hey, @Deedetarsio:twitter , thanks for Etherizing and commenting. Believe me, if you understand a third of my references, you’re getting more of them than I am. 🙂  Delighted to know of your closeness to HCA as we call him in Copenhagen. (There’s a lovely road named for him, goes over a harbor bridge … and the manhole covers have a super silhouette of his profile, which may outrank the concrete at Grauman’s.) When you see HCA, tell him to stop this -en spelling of “Anderson” and do it the right way like me.

Dee DeTarsio

Porter, I only understand about 1/3rd of your references, but since I
also suck at math that’s probably a wild overestimation. I really enjoy
the parts I get–especially the pretty picture of Tivoli Gardens from
Copenhagen. (Did you know I am close, personal friends with Hans
Christian Andersen?)

Anne R. Allen

OMG, I got a mention! Boy, howdy did I stir up a poopstorm with that post. Unfortunately, a lot of long-time reviewers thought I was telling them how to do their job–and according to some–how to dress. (My Boomer humor obviously does not go over well with that demographic.) This post was aimed at over-50 women readers–who are kind of ignored by New York–telling them how much power they have to support their favorite authors. I explaining the review star system is kind of inflated and not to be compared the old TV Guide star system. I wanted them to… Read more »

Porter Anderson

Wouldn’t worry, @annerallen:twitter — I’ve seen that set of bookly women  you’re mentioning in action at conferences, yea, even in the heart of Gotham (just ask @friendgrief:twitter ), and I believe they’re going to be just fine. Seventh Avenue certainly wasn’t giving them any guff last time I saw them take Manhattan. And yes, they’re better dressed than many of my fellow critics. Then again, so am I. As for Amazon reviews, one of the better points about them is that you can go back and edit them. If you find people didn’t seem to get what you were saying,… Read more »


Porter –
That was a compliment, right?

Anne R. Allen

Thanks Porter. I think you’re right about the crisis lovers. I’ve read that self-righteous rage generates the same endorphins as cocaine. There must have been some very buzzed anonymice in the blogosphere this week. 

Things are indeed in upheaval, and people fear change. Shooting the messenger makes them feel less helpless, perhaps.

Victoria Mixon

“death threats from the Amazon Taliban” :))

You did a great job, Anne, and handled the hysterics with a masterful hand. Be proud.

Anne R. Allen

Thanks Victoria. I ran a theater for years, so I’m used to childish people sounding off at me, but this has been a little hairier than I’m used to. Anonymice are meaner. 

Orna Ross

It was a good, sound piece of advice, Anne. Ignore the critics and just go write another one. My favourite screenwriter, Christopher Hampton once said that ‘asking a writer what s/he thinks about critics is like asking a lamp-post what it feels about dogs’. Now you know why. Keep shining the light!

Dee DeTarsio

PS–My HCA is of the -en persuasion (and also happens to be alive and well, living outside of Copenhagen!).

Porter Anderson

Another Swedish interloper, no doubt, @deedetarsio:twitter . Dashing across the bridge from Malmo. My -on is Norwegian, actually, so I can’t call the kettle a funny color.


[…] Writing on the Ether by Porter Anderson via Jane Friedman’s blog. Excellent look at the week in publishing. […]


[…] the awesome Porter Anderson over at Reader Unboxed and make sure you always follow Porter’s Writing on the Ether to keep up with the latest and greatest in […]