Writing on the Ether: Kobo’s Feast of Burden

Top image PA texted story image

Table of Contents

  1. The Spineless Butterball
  2. Man of the Hour
  3. When All the eBooks Vanished
  4. “Active Romance”
  5. “A One to a Zero”


The Spineless Butterball

My turkey, here on the United States’ Thanksgiving Day, is without backbone. 

This is a delightful disruption of tradition, particularly for moderns who enjoy cooking but only to a point, and for those of us who fancy carving the pertinent poultry even less.

I see the boneless turkey as the biggest advance at the American holiday table since we got those awful buckles off everybody’s shoes. I give thanks for this to Butterball. Cooper the Literary Beagle and I send our annual greetings to you as we honor the Principles o’ the Pilgrims with seasonal gluttony, unimpeded by the free-range femur.

On any typical Thanksgiving, of course, having no bone to pick with the centerpiece creature might recall certain spineless members of the industry! the industry!

Not this year.

This year, we tip our cockle hat, in fact, to Canada, which has its own Thanksgiving on the wrong date, of course—they’re Canadian, after all—but which has provided us with a remarkable moment of corporate generosity, well worth your attention.

Back to Table of Contents

Man of the Hour

The "Big Ideas Session" at The Bookseller's FutureBook Conference 2013. Photo: Porter Anderson

The “Big Ideas Session” at The Bookseller’s FutureBook Conference 2013. Photo: Porter Anderson

A week ago today, on the 21st of November, more than 650 of us were gathered in The Bookseller’s magenta-toned FutureBook Conference in London. Nigel Roby, Philip Jones, their efficient staff and many game speakers led us through a good and very pink day of concept and comment. A standout, in fact, was the afternoon’s “Big Ideas Session.” I’ve written about it at Publishing Perspectives in Publish Faster, Publish Less: FutureBook’s “Big Ideas.”

And like a small warm-up to the Big Ideas, a 10-minute session had been inserted into the program for 4 p.m.

Michael Tamblyn

Michael Tamblyn

Michael Tamblyn, content chief at Kobo, was to speak.

I was glad of this. I’d been so glad to have Tamblyn in the implications-of-self-publishing town-hall session I moderated in the Frankfurt Book Fair’s CONTEC Conference in October. He’d been terrific in that setting.

But this time, Tamblyn proceeded to outdo even his London talk’s title: “Infinite Shades of Grey: The Promise and Perils of Self-Publishing in the UK.”

I’ve held on to this until today because I’m thankful for what turned out to be a moment of real courage on Tamblyn’s part. It’s crucial that we recognize and commend him and Kobo on this because we need to encourage our other major corporate players to communicate this way.

I want to flag this for you clearly: Tamblyn broke through the usual code of corporate silence. When things go wrong in large business settings in our digital age, the common mode of response is dictated by Legal. And Legal loves to gag a workforce. No one from the company in question is to speak. No one is to talk. Not even to say things that could help the wider world understand the corporation’s difficult decisions.

What Tamblyn gave us was not only a glimpse of what his company was facing while many of us freely bad-mouthed it for the nine days of the October ordeal, but also a deeply disturbing, problematic issue we all must now take to heart very carefully.

Back to Table of Contents

Opening image from Michael Tamblyn's presentation at London's The FutureBook 2013.

Opening image from Michael Tamblyn’s presentation at The FutureBook 2013.

When All the eBooks Vanished

Here in the States, some of our community were slow to pick up on what was going on for a very long week in the UK self-publishing community last month. (Imagine Americans not paying attention to other cultures’ affairs, I don’t know how this could have happened.)

Kobo Writing LifeTo refresh your memory quickly, shortly after the Frankfurt Book Fair, some tabloid reports in the UK indicated that self-published pornographic ebooks were somehow appearing alongside children’s literature on the Web site of the venerable retailer WHSmith. The (very few) authors behind these offending books apparently were gaming their metadata with titles and phrases that could cause these ebooks to be surfaced in searches using family-fare keywords. Such as “daddy.”

A major supplier of self-published ebooks to WHSmith and others, Kobo abruptly pulled all self-published titles right out of its UK store and without a word of warning.

WHSmithI remember frantic emails and DMs coming in from UK authors, asking me if I had any idea why their books were suddenly vanishing—not from their Kobo store dashboards but from the store itself. They were stunned, ticked off, mystified, and understandably so. Within hours, they had no product to sell. For its part, WHSmith had closed its own site entirely and apparently so hastily that, as The Bookseller’s Jones pointed out, their closed-until-further-notice page carried a typo for days.

Let me allow Tamblyn to put it in his superb way from his FutureBook talk so you can get a sense for what a precipitous moment this represented:

On October 12th, Kobo had a significant catalogue of self-published titles in the UK. Tens of thousands of authors and hundreds of thousands of titles, a thriving part of our UK business. Living the dream, as they say.

On October 14th, we had zero self-published titles available in the UK from zero authors and our 300-year-old retail partner had suspended their web presence.

Kobo got out a couple of statements, its Kobo Writing Life head Mark Lefebvre doing all he could to characterize what was happening. In part, he wrote in one letter to Kobo’s authors (shared with me by an English writer in London):

Our goal at Kobo is not to censor material; we support freedom of expression. Further, we want to protect the reputation of self-publishing as a whole. You have our promise that we will do all we can to ensure the exceptions that have caused this current situation will not have a lasting effect on what is an exciting new channel that connects Readers to a wealth of books.

But, as is usual in these cases, the attacks came pretty quickly, most of them flying the always-busy flag of The Way It Was Handled!

We heard this when Amazon began moving against sock puppetry, you’ll recall. We heard this later, when Goodreads took action against what its regulations classify as inappropriate material on its site. In almost every case, The Way It Was Handled! is what sends the disgruntled crowds into their garages to find the pitchforks.

Image: iStockphoto - spfoto

Image: iStockphoto – spfoto

For my part, I got into it in my Writer Unboxed piece on October 18, Said the Online Retailer to the Entrepreneurial Author, looking for whatever I could find on either side of the experience to get at how rough it was.

My lead sympathies were with the unsuspecting authors whose work was in no way in violation of standards that Kobo or WHSmith or the  most sensitive family in what Jones termed “Middle Britain” might require. My assessment was (and is) that we don’t realize until these crises hit that our new digital sales settings are nowhere near as stable as our physical marketplaces. I wrote that the industry “needs to rethink this pattern of hurting its indispensable authors every time its sales models go pear-shaped.”

As it turns out, this was (and is) very much where Tamblyn’s and Kobo’s collective concerns were focused, as well.

What none of us knew then was that Tamblyn would come to the industry a month later with the forceful candor of the talk he gave at FutureBook.

I dropped Tamblyn a note after last week’s conference to ask if he could share with me the text of his talk. He did far more than that and, admirably, has released the transcript, key graphics, and—with The Bookseller’s collaboration—the 13-minute video of his presentation. You’ll find it all here, very appropriately on the Kobo Writing Life site.

I want to highlight the most important points we get to examine thanks to Tamblyn, and I hope you’ll find time to watch this video of his presentation, too. The laugh track on that tape is authentic. Tamblyn’s colleagues at FutureBook would continue to comment into the evening about how much they appreciated both the laughs and the look inside that difficult nine-day stretch.

Back to Table of Contents

Second image from Michael Tamblyn's

Second image from Michael Tamblyn’s presentation at The FutureBook 2013.

“Active Romance”

Our self-publishing catalog is made up of hundreds of thousands of titles.
It’s mostly fiction.
Of that fiction, much is romance.
Of that romance, some we have come to call “active romance.”

Because of its brevity, Tamblyn said, his presentation might be thought of as “a haiku about self-publishing, its risks and rewards.” The risks he refers to are not, as they appeared from the outside at the time, only on the side of the writer.

Significantly, Tamblyn acknowledges figures we’d touched on in Frankfurt: Kobo Writing life self-publishing authors contribute “10-11% of unit sales globally and all self-published titles, including various aggregators representing 15% or more” of Kobo’s total business.

Pay attention to the number of titles Tamblyn telegraphs in his preso’s graphics as being subject to review. His script calls this “several million titles.” That graphic shows 4 million. Is your head swimming yet?

  1. You have several million titles.
  2. An unknown number of them contain sexual content, suggestive words or adult themes.
  3. Of those, a much, much smaller number have sexual content that is against your Terms of Use.
  4. For both 2 and 3, some are well-labeled and categorized. Some are not.

The response dilemma:

  • If you remove all titles, you don’t have a business.
  • If you remove any titles, some people will consider you a censor.
  • If you remove all titles with sexual content, you are a censor.
  • If you don’t remove the smaller number that contravene your Terms of Use, bad PR and damage to your brand continues.
  • Every book you remove creates an angry author.
  • Every author you remove has a Twitter account.
  • Every journalist wants to find the worst title possible.And even so, fundamentally, you believe that erotica and sexual content should be available.

The complications, while delivered with Vaudeville panache by the engaging Tamblyn, are as compelling as they are funny.

He shows what happens when you try to use automated searches for key words such as “virgin” or “screw,” “breeding” or…”cougars.” (No one asked.)

And while he has everyone laughing, you hear him start tightening the squeeze, with glancing references to digital issues we rarely admit we have not solved, such as vast, unprecedented scale.

22 August 2013 iStock_000018287542XSmall photog StephenHenry4 texted story imageEarlier this year, when looking at Goodreads’ efforts to prevent hostile comment that transgressed its regulations, we considered here on the Ether what it must be to try to monitor a community nearing the size of the population of Australia.

And now, here is Tamblyn questioning a key element of his own company’s burgeoning size:

Can one ever curate a four-million-title database? Is it folly to think that you could?

And, even more important to those of us here about the art as much as about the commerce, Tamblyn masterfully slows the delivery:

Every decision has two kinds of risk. Let the wrong book pass and you have the risk of alienating customers or bad press or breaking the law… But also the other risk, the greater danger, the possibility, however vanishingly small, that the book you are filtering out is the next Tropic of Cancer or Justine or Lolita.

Back to Table of Contents

“A One to a Zero”

Because automation wouldn’t do the job, Kobo drew together its own international flash mob of employees tasked with vetting the mountain of self-publishing called into question and yanked out of the UK store.

At one point, we had people in half a dozen countries working around the clock trying to get books back in as fast as possible. A hundred bizarre conversations. Is it bestiality if it’s sex with a shape shifter? What if both participants are supernatural? What is the age of consent in each territory we sell in? Does it matter if the character is in a coma and everything that takes place is happening in a dream? Is this book in or out?

The punitive action being taken—the part every department labelled Legal always wishes you’d just shut up about—was removal from the store of material that contravenes Kobo’s guidelines:

Some were clearly against our guidelines. Worse, some were perfectly fine, but tangled up in collections of other books requiring one-at-a-time manual review. No books were ever removed from user’s libraries, but a relatively small number of titles were removed from sale.

And in the most chilling moment we encountered in the warm pink of FutureBook, Tamblyn—still at near breakneck speed in his scant 10-minute slot—rolled out the most important thing for you to think about, for me to think about, for this industry to think about, and think again:

In the physical world, to make a book go away is a big deal — you have to burn it or seize it at the border or confiscate if from a shop in a public, visual, galvanizing spectacle. But to de-list, to deactivate, to change a one to a zero, is silent and banal. We should be loud and we should ask why. Authors should give us and every other ebook retailer a hard time when it happens. Because it is so so so much easier now to make something disappear.

Get what he’s saying? Our beloved, late Bradbury would not have had to turn on the flame-throwers in the reality of this future. The operatives of his societal horror could simply get it with a keystroke. Gone. As Tamblyn has it, “a one to a zero.” Your book? What book? There’s no book there anymore.

Do not fail to appreciate the corporate bravery we’re seeing here. Michael Tamblyn is the man who can stroke that key, who can turn your one into a zero, who can disappear your work in an instant—and, in fact, found himself forced to do just that, for a few days in October, with an entire national store of his company’s self-published inventory.

And he is the one who flew to London last week to tell us so.

He is the one so disturbed by this event that—for all his bravura on a conference platform (and those 200-slide presentations I made him leave behind for our panel in Frankfurt)—he really came not to make us laugh but to help us worry.

He is the one who probably mentioned the word “author” more times in that 12 minutes last week than any other speaker did all day at FutureBook. I get 16 references to the word “author” in his presentation transcript.

And when Tamblyn mentioned Kobo’s writers, he talked of them with the same respect, even awe, that you hear in Amazon’s most gifted spokespeople (I’m looking at you, Jon Fine, sorry you weren’t with us in London) and even in the sometimes huckster-ish commentary of Smashwords’ Mark Coker.

For another Ether some time: There is a distinction in how the people of our great digital self-publishing platforms speak of authors and how the people of our major houses of legacy publishing speak of them. We need to listen for this because it involves a fundamental shift in industry dynamics about who is the customer, and are you being served?

For today, a great friend in London just noted to me that she can’t find anything coming out of America today that isn’t about giving thanks. We are that way, aren’t we? And we do have a lot to feel grateful about.

I’m thankful, our word for the day, that Tamblyn said this to us in London:

Authors will push us, will challenge boundaries, will go as far as they can go. And they should. And we will continue to grow into our role of curator. Every ebook retailer now has to wrestle with this. I’m here because we are willing to do some of it out loud, to acknowledge that choices are always being made, and be thoughtful about what they mean. And we will wrestle with the danger and significance of saying “No.” And push always for, and appreciate the power and promise of saying “Yes.”

“Willing to do some of it out loud.” You don’t have to be American to be thankful for that.

Tamblyn wasn’t nominated this year for The FutureBook’s Most Inspiring Digital Publishing Person Award. It went, in fact, to Dominique Raccah of Sourcebooks and you’ll find my Porter Anderson Meets interview with her in Friday’s edition of The Bookseller in London. Raccah, fully worthy of the honor, gave us a grand #PorterMeets interview on Monday.

And I’ll bet Tamblyn’s name is going onto a list for next year. I hope so.

Michael Tamblyn of Kobo delivered The FutureBook’s hardest-hitting and most inspiring session of the day. In a finely arranged conference full of important and edifying detail and personality, Tamblyn seized the room’s collective intelligence with gratifying honesty, pink lightning on a bare stage.

Yep, I’m thankful for it, as I will be every time one of our newsmakers comes to us with the spine it takes to talk turkey about the digital disturbances all around us.

Here’s Tamblyn’s video. And, remember, this and his transcript and some still shots are at the Kobo Writing Life site for you. Have a look, and then tell me:

What did we learn from the Kobo-WHSmith “eroticagate” takedown of books in the UK?

Back to Table of Contents

Main image: At FutureBook 2013, the Fleming Room at Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre, Westminster, set for the opening plenary / Porter Anderson

Posted in Writing on the Ether and tagged , , , , , .

Porter Anderson / @Porter_Anderson

View posts by Porter Anderson / @Porter_Anderson

Porter Anderson (@Porter_Anderson) is a journalist and consultant in publishing. He's The Bookseller's (London) Associate Editor in charge of The FutureBook. He's a featured writer with Thought Catalog (New York), which carries his reports, commentary, and frequent Music for Writers interviews with composers and musicians. And he's a regular contributor of "Provocations in Publishing" with Writer Unboxed. Through his consultancy, Porter Anderson Media, Porter covers, programs, and speaks at publishing conferences and other events in Europe and the US, and works with various players in publishing, such as Library Journal's SELF-e, Frankfurt Book Fair's Business Club, and authors. You can follow his editorial output at Porter Anderson Media, and via this RSS link.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

[…] Porter Anderson’s guest post on Jane Freidman’s blog she goes into the reasons and problems facing the other side of this coin that were presented by […]

Tom Bentley

Porter, your Ether posts have never been lacking a backbone. Too busy dreaming of gravy to banter about Kobos being Bobos, but many thanks to you over the year for not raking much muck, but sifting industry ideas like Solomon (with a touch of Salome).

Happy Thanksgiving!

Porter Anderson


Hey, many thanks, Tom,

Such kind words and so poorly earned in these bleary typo-chasing nights, lol. Really appreciate your note and hope you’re having a super Thanksgiving, yourself! Trying to finish some project work quickly here to get on to the gravy, myself. 🙂

If it’s ever more than a touch of Salome, by the way, protect your neck.

Cheers! 🙂

AJ Sikes

Thankful is what I am for these Ether posts of yours, Porter. Great stuff. I was one of those attackers, pitchfork in hand as I tweeted and retweeted my fellow authors’ pain and loss on 12-14 October. Hearing Tamblyn’s full disclosure puts me of a mind to offer the man (and company) an apology. On the point Tamblyn makes, about ones becoming zeroes, that’s…that’s kind of a thing. That’s big. In this Cloud-age we’re living in now, with media vanishing left and right, the power to burn Alexandria no longer requires an angry horde of invaders. More than the potential… Read more »

Porter Anderson

@f8089fc9074b34812a8c6b0347bb80ba:disqus Hey, Aaron, apologies for the late response, had a bit of a “working holiday” here, lol. You were not alone in your hostility to Kobo, of course. I’m hoping that folks are getting this piece around to folks because, like so many of us, your reaction — wow, now I understand a lot better — is precisely what we all feel. Note that Monday at 9a Eastern (2p London time), Michael Tamblyn will be my guest for a live Twitter interview, part of my Porter Anderson Meets series at The Bookseller in London. If you can join us, look… Read more »


Hi Porter, at last the Kobogate material. You probably remember that I was upset when the wipeout happened, I was doing a big promo at the time, so I had to erase all my book links to Kobo in order not to upset my potential readers who shop at Kobo. I knew what the reason was, and, of course, it’s was a desperate measure. I just naively thought that Kobo had a working filter for explicit content in place. I bought two different types of Kobo e-readers in September and gave them away as presents. At least, their hardware is… Read more »

Porter Anderson

@GrigoryRyzhakov:disqus Hey, Grisha, Thanks for chiming in here, and for the holiday wishes, too! I do remember you took quite a bad hit in the Kobo-WHSmith affair last month. I think it was The Bookseller’s Philip Jones who wrote in one of his pieces on the matter that he, like so many of us, had assumed that electronic filters were in place to prevent such things as porn turning up in kids’ sections of online stores .. only to learn from Michael Tamblyn’s fine comments at The FutureBook that not only are such filters not in place but they’re beastly… Read more »


“We are immensely relieved that self-published books are back in our UK catalog.”

Apparently, this excludes me. My books are not back yet.

Anyway, I hope you’re enjoying the holiday break, Porter.

Porter Anderson

I think I’d be sure to be in touch with Kobo, then, Grisha. If your books aren’t back in the UK store, then there must be some issue involved. As far as I know, most of the books vetted and approved for sale should have returned by now.


I’m used to tough luck, Porter 🙂 Thank you!

Porter Anderson

I’m learning from a post by Anne Allen, Grisha, that you should write to writinglife@kobo.com if you’re not already in touch about books not returning to the store. I’m sure this is happening in a number of instances. With 400,000 titles to vet, something’s going to be lost in the shuffle of getting things back into place. Check in with them.


Cheers, Porter. I will contact them. Good to know that Kobo is vetting its catalog now. I mean it’s a bookseller’s responsibility to bring the quality content to the reader. So I understand the massive scale of the task.

[…] Table of Contents The Spineless Butterball Man of the Hour When All the eBooks Vanished “Active Romance” “A One to a Zero” The Spineless Butterball My turkey, here on the United States’ Thanksgiving Day, is without backbone. This is a delightful…  […]

Lexa Cain

I’m left feeling everyone’s an alarmist and should just get a grip. People seemed more upset over the Kobo “debacle” and “censorship” than true disasters like the Philippines. If the worst thing in an author’s life is their erotica book wasn’t available from Kobo for a while, then they lead a pretty privileged life. Is it really about “censorship” or is it perhaps that the infinite shades of grey are really one big shade of green = the money? — and how neither authors nor retailers want to lose any. On a lighter note, “Is it bestiality if he transforms… Read more »

Porter Anderson

@LexaCain:disqus Hey, Lexa, thanks for jumping in. Of course, natural disasters (and manmade acts of physical aggression, for that matter, such as warfare), carry more sheer suffering and emergency weight than issues of the marketplace. I’m sure nobody’s suggesting that an ebook-selling crisis outweighs questions of life and death. On the other hand, the issue behind the Kobo-WHSmith affair is a lot bigger and more serious than the fact of someone’s erotica book not being available. For one thing, all self-published books — not just erotica, everything — in Kobo’s UK store disappeared in the mid-October event. Without warning. That’s… Read more »

Lexa Cain

It’s great you have so much respect for Mr Tamblyn, as do I. I think he did the very best he could in a difficult situation, and I think he acted appropriately and don’t fault him for “how it was handled.” I also realize that the 650 at the conference (along with many, many others) are far more experienced in the book business than I. But I can’t help thinking about digital disappearance versus physical obliteration. Around 1922, the heirs to the Bram Stoker estate won a copyright infringement case which resulted in every print of the film “Nosferatu” being… Read more »

Porter Anderson

It’s not about who knows more than whom, Lexa. I think I’m very receptive to your comments and always as welcoming as I can be. You’re entitled to your opinions, you express them well, and you speak up for yourself with good and ready energy. No one here is saying that you don’t know more than anyone else, are they? I’d appreciate it if you wouldn’t imply that in some way your assertions are being denigrated. They are not. Not here.

Thanks again for all your input.

Lexa Cain

You’re not saying it — I am, and not in a sarcastic way. Of course you and Jane (and other guest posters here) know more than I do about the publishing industry. That’s why I come here — because I learn so much! I’m just worried I may lack key info or be seeing only a portion of a larger subject and my replies to you may be naive. You’re always welcoming, and I never fail to learn something when I read your posts and replies.

Porter Anderson

Oh, good, thanks. I was worried because it’s all too easy in this digital dance for someone — myself maybe more than others since I’m on the commentary circuit — to come off as smarter-than-thou. And the truth is that while some of us are exposed to more debate and discussion about the industry! the industry! these days, we’re all feeling our way along and trying to make sense of a kind of shape-shifting reality that’s nowhere near being settled. (That’s one of the reasons you’ll see me from time to time laying in to people who love to predict… Read more »

Jamie Chavez

After 5 days of intestinal flu (fun! fun! fun!) I’m back and catching up. Just now reading this Ether and it’s fantastic. I appreciate how you pull it all together, Porter. Hope you spent some time with loved ones this weekend, not just us book geeks. 🙂 All the best to you!

Porter Anderson


Thanks, Jamie,

Appreciate the kind words, and hope you’re feeling better!


On Twitter: @Porter_Anderson

Lara Schiffbauer

Authors will push us, will challenge boundaries, will go as far as they can go. And they should. And we will continue to grow into our role of curator. Every ebook retailer now has to wrestle with this. I’m here because we are willing to do some of it out loud, to acknowledge that choices are always being made, and be thoughtful about what they mean. And we will wrestle with the danger and significance of saying “No.” And push always for, and appreciate the power and promise of saying “Yes.” I like this. Trying to explain why might be… Read more »

Porter Anderson

@laraschiffbauer:disqus Hey, Lara, Thanks for this — very much your framing of it as a question of self-publishing authors and their platforms working to “hold each other accountable in a respectful manner.” I do think you’re right that there’s a bit of an every-person-for-himself mentality in place at this point, probably inevitable in the celebrated independence of the self-publishing author. If you go it alone, the temptation to think of your own interests first may be perfectly natural. But as you’re saying, the good of the consumer, the reader — the point, after all — is not always going to… Read more »

[…] Writ­ing on the Ether:  Kobo’s Feast of Burden […]

[…] Anderson has a great article on Jane Friedman‘s blog, “When All the eBooks Vanished”, regarding the 9-days disaster in October when WHSmith shut down, and Kobo pulled all its […]

[…] #Porter­Meets live Twit­ter inter­view sub­ject, Kobo’s Michael Tam­blyn, had The Future­Book Con­fer­ence audi­ence in Lon­don in the palm of his hand as he recounted what the com­pany went through dur­ing the […]

[…] WRITING ON THE ETHER | Kobo’s Feast of Bur­den | JANEFRIEDMAN.COM […]