How to Plot and Outline Without Using a Formula

by procsilas / via Flickr

by procsilas / via Flickr

Note from Jane: Today’s post is adapted from the introduction to Book Architecture by Stuart Horwitz (@book_arch).


I founded the company Book Architecture 15 years ago because I was tired of being called a “book doctor”—as if I had some kind of magic pill or syringe I could inject into a manuscript that would cure all of its ills. It doesn’t work that way; at least it doesn’t if you’re not using a formula.

Writers everywhere need help building something beautiful, solid, and original, and that takes a method.

The method I’d like to suggest has three main concepts:

  1. Scene
  2. Series
  3. Theme

1. Scene

If you can find your 99 scenes, and if you can put them in the right order, then you will be all set. That’s kind of a joke, but I’ve seen it happen. Please note: 99 is a placeholder. You might have 72, or 138, etc. But when we think of our scenes as comprising a certain number, and therefore separate from each other, we can get the flexibility we need to move things around, to discard some and brainstorm others.

Your scenes are where things happen, and because something happened, your scenes are where something changes. Your scenes are where you “show, don’t tell,” where you use description and dialogue, but they won’t be animated at the level of the full-length narrative, unless you use series.

2. Series

What is a series? Let me first tell you what a series is not: it is not an interrelated series of books in the same genre that have a lot of the same characters. (It is related to that, but we don’t have to worry about that right now.)

Series here is defined as: The repetition and variation of a narrative element so that the repetition and variation creates meaning.

You may have heard repetition and variation applied to art in general: the use of melody in music, the architectural pattern.

Repetition and variation of a narrative element—what is that? A narrative element is anything that can be identified in a reader’s mind as something discrete, for example, a person, a place, a thing, a relationship or a phrase. In fact, the repetitions and variations of series are how a person becomes a character, how a place becomes a setting, how a thing or object becomes a symbol, how a relationship becomes a dynamic, and how a repeated phrase becomes a key to the philosophy of the work.

Repetition and variation of a narrative element creates meaning. The repetitions and variations of each series form individual narrative arcs.

Writers need to gain the skills to have these arcs interact, intersect, and collide—to braid these threads of series into a whole tapestry. All of your series should be about the same thing, because your book can only be about one thing. And we call that one thing our theme.

3. Theme

Your book can only be about one thing. One student asked me, “What about two things? Can my book be about two things?” You know those students. To which I replied, “Yes, provided that those two things are about one thing.”

This is as close as I get to a should. You should be able to say what the theme of your work is in one sentence. You don’t have to worry about whether that one sentence is a cliché. Better to spend your time worrying about whether you believe that one sentence.

“It’s not how you fall in life, it’s whether you pick yourself up.”

Do you believe that? I do. The originality comes from the clothing that you put on the theme, such as:

“How a girl goes from being a drunk crying lesbian to just being a drunk lesbian.”

When you get your theme, you can arrange your series around it, and then use what repeats and varies to drill down to the level of individual scenes to see what your work is still missing, what has to go, and what kind of opportunity you really have in front of you.

Scene, series, and theme. A relatively simple way to think about writing. There are many good books on the market today on the subject of scene. My use of theme is original in its application but not its definition. Series, though, fills a void in the writing world, and it has produced attention, a little controversy, and some a-ha! moments for writers.

There are many different types of series, as I mentioned before.

  • Character series: when a person repeats and varies, they become a character
  • Object series: when an object repeats and varies, it becomes a symbol
  • Phrase series: when a phrase is repeated, it becomes the message or the mantra of the work
  • Relationship series: when two or more individuals evolve a dynamic
  • Location series: when different scenes take place in the same locale, adding extra significance to it

There is, of course, an event series as well, but here we have to be careful or we’ll end up privileging these events above all other aspects of the work. We’ll call the events a plot and make everything else take a backseat.

When I work with writers, they all want to talk with me about their plot. “What is this plot you speak of?” I ask, and they say something like, “You know, everything that happens … the important parts … the stuff that comes together, and you know, means something.”

When we talk about plot as separate from the characters, the symbols, the locales, the dialogue, and the philosophical introspection, what we are doing is privileging events over everything else. But nothing exists in a vacuum.

Writing guides that treat everything separately make returning to unity that much harder. I don’t want to sound like one of those people who think they’ve found the answer while everybody else is wrong. I just feel that current approaches to writing structure will inevitably box you in. Nowhere is this more true than for the subject of plot. Everybody says pretty much the exact same thing. There is a “universal story” that we all must adhere to: narrative should be divided into a “three-act” structure of conflict, crisis, and resolution. Within these three acts, there are more specific landmarks such as the first “pinch point,” where we are reminded of the antagonistic force, or the “midpoint,” where we get a twist that sends the main character into a new world.

It looks like this:

Plot Formula

This is good stuff to think about, just as long as we don’t all use it at the same time and create a bunch of narratives that resemble each other because, you know, we all used the same formula. A lot of great books use this formula, but a lot of great books don’t.

Because we have our series, we don’t need a formula. Book Architecture By tracking our series, we can straighten out 99 percent of what is wrong with our work. I’m serious; that figure is probably low. You can evaluate your series arc to ensure consistency with your various throughlines, become aware of any gaping holes, and create moments of emotional impact.


Want to know more about this method? Check out Book Architecture by Stuart Horwitz.

Posted in Guest Post, Writing Advice and tagged , , , .

Stuart Horwitz

As founder and principal of Book Architecture, Stuart has spent over fifteen years helping writers become authors. Book Architecture’s clients have reached the bestseller list in both fiction and nonfiction, and have appeared on Oprah!, The Today Show, The Tonight Show, and in the most prestigious journals in their respective fields.

Stuart is an award-winning essayist and poet, who has taught writing at Grub Street of Boston and Brown University. He holds two masters degrees—one in Literary Aesthetics from NYU, which helps him a lot with this work—and one in East Asian Studies from Harvard with a concentration in Medieval Japanese Buddhism, which helps him get out of bed in the morning. He lives in Rhode Island with his wife and two daughters.

Join the conversation

23 Comments on "How to Plot and Outline Without Using a Formula"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
philipparees

Ordered without pause for thought. THIS makes perfect sense and whew I can crawl out from all those other prescriptive guides that made me feel suicidal!

henya

Right! Hate…hate…hate…hate formulas. I cringe when told I should follow a scripted recipe. So! I’m going to see what you have to say…off to order the book…

trackback

[…] by procsilas / via Flickr Note from Jane: Today’s post is adapted from the introduction to Book Architecture by Stuart Horwitz (@book_arch).  […]

Deborah Lucas

How intelligent! It makes perfect sense, especially after reading a complex web of series in “All the Light We Cannot See.” Perfect timing to help me restructure my memoir.

I’m still struggling with your idea of only one theme in a novel–maybe one theme for each person who reads it. In our writers’ bookclub, we never agree on very much, but it is always interesting to hear what other writers pull out of a manuscript.

A.K.Andrew @artyyah

This is a great way to simplify things, and yet at the same time get a grip! Thank you. Loved the drunk lesbian example on being specific and individualizing theme.

trackback

[…] Stuart Horowitz discusses how to plot without using a formula on Jane Friedman’s blog. […]

trackback

[…] is the underpinning of any good story. Stuart Horwitz discusses how to plot and outline without a formula, P.J. Reece shows how to find the heart of your story, and Weifarer talks about using parallel […]

Professional Essays

it reallly a awesome post.thanks for sharing your experience with us it helps many people to survive and enjoy in college life.

trackback

[…] Plot And Outline […]

Tom Mickey

Stuart, loved reading this post. thanks so much. Can I use this material for a nonfiction book I am into at the moment? I seem to be stuck. Too little, too much, etc. etc.

trackback

[…] How to Plot a Story and Outline Without Using a Formula […]

trackback

[…] How to Plot a Story and Outline Without Using a Formula […]

trackback

[…] story: Molly Green’s Blog, How a Pantser Outlines; The Kill Zone, #1 Rule of First Drafts; Jane Friedman, How to Plot a Story, and Writer Unboxed, Four Questions to Ask When Your Writing is […]

trackback

[…] Jane Friedman’s blog that made the idea of theme a bit less murky for me. In her post about plot and outline, Jane talks about being able to describe your story’s theme in one sentence. She says, […]

trackback

[…] How to Plot and Outline without Using a Formula – Jane Friedman offers some thoughts on the architecture of books. […]

Rebekah Gregory
I know I’m finding this about 1+ years late, but as a new writer, I was frustrated with all the formulas I was finding out there so I was researching this very topic and found this post. ‘Writing guides that treat everything separately make returning to unity that much harder. I don’t want to sound like one of those people who think they’ve found the answer while everybody else is wrong. I just feel that current approaches to writing structure will inevitably box you in’ and ‘A lot of great books use this formula, but a lot of great books… Read more »
trackback

[…] Jane Friedman […]

trackback

[…] How to Plot and Outline Without Using a Formula […]

wpDiscuz