How Kindle Press Made My Novel a Bestseller

Kindle Press

Today’s guest post is by novelist and reporter Rick Pullen. Note: Kindle Press is no longer accepting submissions and Kindle Scout has shut down.

After 38 agents turned down my political thriller, Naked Ambition, my friend Ron Sauder, a niche book publisher on Maryland’s Eastern Shore, urged me to try Amazon’s Kindle Scout. Kindle Scout allows Amazon customers to vote on which books they’d like to see published based on reading a few opening chapters. After a month, the books are evaluated by an Amazon editorial team, who take into consideration the number of nominations a book has received, then select some books for publication as part of Amazon’s Kindle Press program.

The logic behind Ron’s recommendation was that I was an unknown and agents give about 15 seconds of attention to query letters, so they really had no idea what I had written. After 38 rejections and only a few half-hearted responses, he asked, why not get my name out there and test the waters with readers?

I quickly learned writers must first sign a contract with Amazon, not knowing if their book will be selected. If it is, Kindle Press immediately owns both your ebook rights and your audio rights and you can’t back out of the deal. You keep only your print rights since Kindle Press doesn’t publish or distribute print books. While Kindle Press has sold a lot of ebooks, it has yet to publish its first audio book even though Amazon owns the largest audiobook company, Audible.

I’m no social media maven, but I took to Facebook and email—the extent of my social media knowledge—to urge friends and family to vote for my novel. I also had a friend re-launch my web page, which had been dormant for years, but I don’t think that helped at all with the launch.

A lot of friends and business colleagues shared my request and I ended up with 1,200 votes after the 30-day process. Kindle Press quickly picked up my novel, which meant everyone who nominated it would get a free early copy of the ebook—part of the incentive to nominate a Kindle Scout book.

I handed over my manuscript and a Kindle Press editor from Kirkus made minimal grammatical changes throughout the copy, almost all of which I accepted. It was obvious from some of her edits there was a wide generational gap between my knowledge and hers.

Naked AmbitionI was required to submit my own cover, which I had already been working on with the help of my creative director at my magazine. (I work in magazine publishing.) Creating a cover was quite a story in itself (read about it at my website). It started out looking like a romance novel, then soft porn, and—finally—after consulting with designers and marketers at a couple of publishing conferences, a real thriller novel cover. I realized I still had a lot to learn.

I also had to coordinate the publication of the CreateSpace print-on-demand version with the publication of the Kindle Press ebook.

Finally, on May 3, Kindle Press launched Naked Ambition and I quickly became what my friend Ron describes as “one of the ninety-nine percenters.” My novel hit No. 1 on three Amazon thriller lists by May 20. I was floored. I was a complete unknown in the thriller genre and my book was suddenly—if briefly—hanging out with some of the greats who live much of their lives on that other bestseller list owned by the The New York Times.

I was immediately invited to become a member of a private Kindle Press Authors Facebook page and that’s when I began to get another education in publishing, or at least a Kindle Press publishing education.

Naked Ambition was published in Kindle Press’s second year of operation. In 2015, it published about 90 novels. By the end of 2016, Kindle Press had published a total of 218 books. Megan Muldur, the managing editor and defacto publisher, acknowledged to me that her staff was stretched thin by the middle of 2016. She was gradually adding more staff but that still didn’t keep authors’ emails from going unanswered for long periods of time. Some of mine went for months and I still have some outstanding. But being a magazine editor with a small staff of my own and working with a lot of freelance writers, I know exactly what Megan is facing. She is struggling with the same growing pains faced by any suddenly very successful business enterprise.

I have talked with her by phone and we have emailed back and forth and she has been very supportive of my book, even when I didn’t know it. One time when my sales suddenly surged, I wrote to ask why and found, after the fact, that Kindle Press had been promoting my novel. No complaints there, although it would have been nice to know ahead of time (although, frankly, I don’t know what I would have done with the information). It’s just nice not to fly blind, which is what I feel I have done ever since I decided to write a novel.

Some 185 Kindle Press authors had joined the private Facebook page by the end of 2016. I learned that many had a lot fewer nominations than I did, but were still chosen for publication. And many spoke of knowing writers who had thousands of more nominations who were turned down. It became clear that Kindle Press may use nominations as an indicator of interest, but it is like every other publisher and looks for story and quality of writing before making a decision to publish.

That of course begs the question: Why bother with the Kindle Scout nominating system at all? Is it a gimmick? It took me a while before I figured that out. But if you understand Amazon, the answer becomes obvious. Those who nominate books create a pool of initial reviewers to help promote Kindle Press ebooks when they are first published. Voters, after all, not only get a free book if they voted for a winner, they are the first to receive it. And everyone knows early reviews help sell books. So each Kindle Press “winner” has a volunteer marketing force in place from day one of publication.

But the Kindle Press business model just also happens to create new data for Amazon—the ultimate data-driven company. And this is data on some of its more engaged customers. It can use this information to track their buying habits and then market other books and products to them. It also urges them to do more reviews and thus promote more books and sales on Amazon. It’s a never-ending marketing loop and Amazon wins every time. And of course, a few writers like me get a wonderful free ride on the breaking crest of sales.

Kindle Press not only marketed my book well, but also pays well. Its royalty on domestic ebooks is 50%. Also, Kindle Press pays its authors a full royalty on all books sold through Amazon’s Kindle Unlimited subscription service. (Self-published authors are paid a variable rate based on pages read.)

Finally, by November, sales had dropped precipitously. So after seven months, I received an email from Kindle Press telling me my book would be promoted for 99 cents for the month of December. Other writers told me this usually happens after a book has been on the market for about 90 days. But at that time, my book was still selling well, so I’m sure the algorithm on my sales told Megan and her colleagues to wait on a price reduction promotion.

So in December sales again shot up. I sold more in a day than I had the entire month of November, but at 99 cents (that’s a 49-cent royalty), I wasn’t going to get rich. But at the dawn of my fiction-writing career, I’m more interested in readers finding me than making a boatload of money. The yacht can wait.

Then in mid-December, Megan offered me a fat one-time royalty to place my book in Amazon’s new Prime Readers program for the first three months of 2017. This is a new program that offers Amazon Prime customers a choice of 10 free books at a time from a list of 1,000, of which a third are turned over every month. And yet Kindle Press still pays me a royalty. It was an offer I couldn’t turn down, because thrillers were only a fraction of the books in the program. I was asked to keep the offer quiet, which I did. But I still scanned the Kindle Press authors Facebook page in search of answers about the program and learned a lesson in marketing.

Other Kindle Press authors who took part explained that the free giveaways would be counted in my novel’s Amazon sales rankings. That’s extremely important because it keeps my book visible to those who are not Amazon Prime members and are still paying for it. On Amazon, where there are more than five million ebooks, mine was again breaking into the top 1,000 in sales. But more importantly, my book was ranked in the top 15 on Amazon’s thriller novel lists right next to many New York Times best sellers.

It’s all about a book’s visibility and mine suddenly had it again. The advantage for me is not only would I get the lump sum royalty from the Prime Readers program, but I would also continue to receive royalties every month from those who were still buying my novel for $3.49. This doesn’t hurt sales of my $14.99 CreateSpace print novel either!

My friend Ron was right about making a name for myself. Last July I signed a contract with an agent who had actually read my novel and did not rely on one of his readers to send me a rejection. He had previously turned me down—not because he didn’t like my book, he said, but because he feared it would not become a breakout novel. When he found it was selling well, we got together for brunch in New York.

I now face a dilemma with my second novel, a sequel to my first and possibly one of four or more in a series. My new agent told me traditional publishers don’t want to pick up a series once it has begun. He asked two imprints right after he signed me and neither was interested despite my strong sales numbers. While he said my sales are impressive for a first-time novelist (approaching 20,000), a traditional publisher still wants to own it all—print and ebook rights to everything.

There are a lot of other authors out there just like me. We’ve done fairly well with non-traditional publishing, but we want to explore our potential. But with the publishing world changing so rapidly, is that really a smart idea? Would I be locking myself into a long-term contract with a dinosaur?

Jane Friedman noted recently that 70% of fiction is sold in ebook format and about 50% of all domestic book sales are through Amazon. How does an author ignore Amazon? Frankly, as my friend Ron has reminded me again and again, Amazon is a marketing machine. My book sales are about 97% ebook and 3% print. From an author’s view, that is the only weakness of Kindle Press. Print books are not part of their business plan and frankly I can’t blame them.

Despite my Kindle Press’s impressive record, my agent assures me he can navigate the roiling waters and changing currents of traditional publishing today, taking full advantage of all of its digital dynamics and minimizing its negative troglodyte characteristics. He’s told me while traditional publishers may have a reputation as living in another geological age, they are pretty savvy at digital sales and print marketing.

We’ll see what happens. What would you do?

Posted in E-Books, Publishing Industry and tagged , , , , , , .

Rick Pullen, an award-winning investigative reporter and magazine editor, is the author of Naked Ambition, a political thriller. He is a member of the National Press Club, Mystery Writers of America and International Thriller Writers. He lives in Fredericksburg, Virginia. In 2015 he was a finalist for Editor of the Year and is a member of the FOLIO 100—the 100 most influential people in magazine publishing. For more background, visit his website or Amazon author page.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Cathy Shouse

What a great story of your debut novel finding such success. Congrats and thanks for sharing all the fascinating details! To answer your question, if you have the option–and the amount of work wouldn’t send you to an early grave–I would keep my relationship with Amazon and publish the rest of your series there, while starting a new series for a traditional publisher. There is validity to participating in both worlds if you have the chance. I’m also a reporter and have a few questions for you, if you’ve got the time. lol I’m sure your novel is great and… Read more »

Anna Erishkigal

Thank you for bringing us honest and unbiased fact so we can make good decisions.

Deanna Cabinian

Great informative article. Congrats on your success, Rick!

Ann Everett

Rick, As a new Kindle Scout winner, this article furnished a lot of valuable info. Thanks so much for sharing. To answer your question, this is just my opinion, but I don’t understand why any author still seeks traditional publishing. I have friends who have been published by a major house and their experience has not been a good one. Unless a book comes out of the gate with mega sales, (I’m talking within 90 days) big houses won’t give it the time of day—and because they own all the rights, the author has no way of promoting to boost… Read more »

Anne Carrole

Great success. As another Kindle Scout/Kindle Press author I went with KP for my next in series and no regrets so far but, at this stage, I am looking for discoverability and I have personal reasons for enjoying the freedom of writing to my deadline and not a publisher’s deadline, which KP has allowed me to do. Congratulations and will be looking for you on the NYTimes best seller list this time around! 🙂


First off, Congratulations! Secondly, why do you need traditional publishing? You have what a lot of others don’t have: visibility. You can leverage that with your next book and go from there. Eventually, you can go hybrid but why saddle yourself now, especially when you have knowledge like this and visibility. Honestly build your own platform.

[…] How Kindle Press Made My Novel a Bestseller (Jane Friedman) After 38 agents turned down my political thriller, Naked Ambition, my friend Ron Sauder, a niche book publisher on Maryland’s Eastern Shore, urged me to try Amazon’s Kindle Scout. Kindle Scout allows Amazon customers to vote on which books they’d like to see published based on reading a few opening chapters. After a month, the books are evaluated by an Amazon editorial team, who take into consideration the number of nominations a book has received, then select some books for publication as part of Amazon’s Kindle Press program. […]

Austin Gisriel

Thanks for the insights, and good luck to you as you continue to navigate today’s publishing world.

Stephen Black

Thank you very much for all of this info, especially the info related to ebook and audio rights. And all of the “inside” stuff, like the private page for Kindle authors. Congratulations and I wish you continued success!

Linda Bahnan

This ‘wide generational gap’ vis a vis grammar, I’m fascinated. Presumably, she’s younger than you? Maybe not. Older, then. What difference do either of these make to grammar?

Al Bergstein

My editor, who is in her forties, totally missed many historical references I made in my memoir, regarding the 60s, 70s and 80s. I had to rewrite portions to explain what I was talking about, though anyone who lived through that era would have understood. It was a good lesson, and I’m glad I paid her to give me that advice, among other input.


Congrats! It’s great to know more about the innovations taking place in publishing. My only beef is that for those who choose traditional publishing or self-publishing outside of Amazon’s programs, they will not publish reviews from anyone that did not purchase the book on Amazon. If you received it as a gift, borrowed from a library or a friend, or bought it anywhere else – they will not publish a review. The army they amass under the Kindle Press agreement, however, are given free copies in hopes it will be reviewed – and then Amazon publishes those reviews, which of… Read more »

Jane Friedman

Hi Deb – While it’s true that Amazon places priority on reviews that are “verified purchases,” it’s still possible to write and leave a review for a book or product not purchased through Amazon. Its policy states, “Customers can submit 5 non-Amazon Verified Purchase reviews each week.” That doesn’t mean the reviews will show up automatically, and they may be at greater risk of being removed if Amazon believes the reviews were purchased or incentivized (other than through a free advance review copy). More here for those who want the full background:

Jenifer Ruff

Loved this article. Thank you for sharing.

Al Bergstein

Rick, I enjoyed this article. I’m in the process of deciding on using an agent, self publishing, or using Amazon. I’m not clear why you wouldn’t have simply self published, using a publisher that could also put hard copy books in bookstores if your book took off? I’m of the belief that, since I am not sure I will find an agent, that I will have to self-publish. But I don’t think I would end up going purely with Amazon. To be clear, I own a Kindle, and read a lot of books on it, but still, for some books… Read more »

Lilia Fabry

Cool, thanks for sharing this!

[…] Rick Pullen shares how Kindle Press made his novel a best seller. […]


WOW!: “… writers must first sign a contract with Amazon, not knowing if their book will be selected. If it is, Kindle Press immediately owns both your ebook rights and your audio rights and you can’t back out of the deal.” Seems like an awful lot to give up early on, although not, of course, compared to traditional publishing.

Randileigh Kennedy

So glad I found this article. I currently have a book submitted to Kindle Scout and have been feverishly drumming up nominations, so I certainly appreciate your honesty as to how many nominations you had yourself to help gauge where I’m at (understanding of course that nomination stats alone don’t make or break the outcome). I have been fortunate enough to meet some other kind folks who also went through this process, and I have learned a lot already (in addition to already having 5 other books self-published on Amazon). I love reading successful stories like this and I wish… Read more »

Karl Braungart

Rick, I enjoyed reading How Kindle Press Made My Novel a Bestseller. (Wish I knew about it earlier.) Anyway, I enjoyed reading opinions and appreciated getting advice from those who commented. I’ve ordered Naked Ambition. Hope you write a sequel to this story to let us know how you’re doing. Good luck.

[…] “How Kindle Press Made My Novel a Bestseller” on Jane Friedman […]